C++Talk.NET

Gerd Schmitt · Guest

Hi gurus et al.

My collegues and I encouter a somewhat strange behaviour of our
compilers and are unsure whether or not the compiler is right.
It seems that anything declared protected in a base class can only be
accessed by the child class if it is the same instance.
I allway thought the C++ type system only relies on static types. Am I
wrong?

It would be nice if someone could enligthen me

Gerd

Here the sample code wich does not compile:

class A
{
int privA;

protected:
int protA;
void protMethA(A* a) { privA = a->privA; }

public:
int pub;
void pubMethA(A* a) { privA = a->privA; }
};

class B : public A
{
int privB;

protected:
void protMethB(A* a)
{
protA = 5;
a->protMethA(this);
int tmp = a->protA;
}

public:
void pubMethB(A* a)
{
protA = 3;
a->protMethA(this);
int tmp = a->protA;
}
void pubMethB2(B* rhs)
{
rhs->privB = 5;
}
};

int main()
{
A a;
B b;

a.pubMethA(&b);
b.pubMethB(&a);

return 0;
}

John Harrison · Guest

"Gerd Schmitt" <gschmitt (AT) it-studio (DOT) de> wrote